Cable vs Streaming vs Antenna: Complete Cost Analysis for Milwaukee Viewers

Tired of your $180+ monthly Spectrum bill? You're not alone. Milwaukee residents are cutting the cord in record numbers, but which alternative actually saves money long-term? We've crunched the real numbers on cable vs streaming vs antenna setups to show you exactly what you'll pay - and what you'll get - over the next 5 years.

Spoiler alert: The right setup could save you over $3,000 in five years while actually improving your viewing experience.

The Real Cost Breakdown: What Milwaukee Residents Actually Pay

Spectrum Cable TV (Current Milwaukee Pricing)

| Package | Monthly Cost | Year 1 Total | 5-Year Total | |---------|--------------|--------------|--------------| | TV Select | $84.99 | $1,020 | $5,100 | | TV Silver | $114.99 | $1,380 | $6,900 | | TV Gold | $154.99 | $1,860 | $9,300 |

Note: Prices include typical promotional pricing ending after 12 months, then jumping to standard rates

Hidden Costs You'll Pay:

• HD Technology Fee: $10/month
• Broadcast TV Fee: $18.85/month
• Regional Sports Fee: $8.85/month
• DVR Service: $12.99/month
• Additional cable boxes: $7.50/month each
• Total hidden fees: ~$58/month extra

Streaming Services Alternative

| Service Combination | Monthly Cost | Year 1 Total | 5-Year Total | |---------------------|--------------|--------------|--------------| | Basic Sports Package | $65.98 | $792 | $3,960 | | Complete Package | $95.97 | $1,152 | $5,760 | | Premium Package | $125.96 | $1,512 | $7,560 |

Basic Sports Package includes:

• Hulu + Live TV ($82.99) OR YouTube TV ($82.99)
• Internet only from Spectrum ($49.99)
• Streaming device ($50 one-time)

TV Antenna + Streaming Hybrid

| Setup Type | Upfront Cost | Monthly Cost | 5-Year Total | |------------|--------------|--------------|--------------| | Budget Setup | $180 | $49.99 | $3,180 | | Premium Setup | $450 | $69.98 | $3,649 | | Ultimate Setup | $850 | $89.97 | $4,249 |

5-Year Cost Projection: The Numbers That Matter

Traditional Spectrum Cable TV Gold

• Year 1: $1,860 (promotional rate)
• Years 2-5: $2,100/year (standard rate)
• 5-Year Total: $10,260
• Average monthly: $171

Streaming Alternative (YouTube TV + Internet)

• Years 1-5: $1,152/year consistent
• 5-Year Total: $5,760
• Average monthly: $96
• 5-Year Savings vs Cable: $4,500

Antenna + Streaming Hybrid (Premium Setup)

• Year 1: $1,289 (includes equipment)
• Years 2-5: $840/year
• 5-Year Total: $3,649
• Average monthly: $61
• 5-Year Savings vs Cable: $6,611

What You Actually Get: Channel Lineup Comparison

Spectrum TV Gold (150+ channels)

Sports: ESPN, ESPN2, FS1, FS2, FanDuel Sports Network, NFL Network, NBA TV, MLB Network Local: FOX6, TMJ4, WISN, CBS58 (HD) News: CNN, FOX News, MSNBC, BBC World News Entertainment: HBO, Showtime, Starz included Missing: Netflix, Hulu, Disney+ (separate subscriptions needed)

Streaming Package (YouTube TV Example)

Sports: ESPN, ESPN2, FS1, FS2, NFL Network, NBA TV, MLB Network Local: FOX6, TMJ4, WISN, CBS58 (HD + streaming quality) News: CNN, FOX News, MSNBC, BBC World News Entertainment: Basic cable networks Missing: FanDuel Sports Network, HBO/Premium channels (add-on required) Bonus: Unlimited DVR, watch anywhere

Antenna + Streaming Hybrid

Over-the-Air (FREE): FOX6, TMJ4, WISN, CBS58 (better picture quality than cable) Additional channels: MeTV, Antenna TV, Heroes & Icons, Grit Streaming add-ons: Netflix, Disney+, specific sports apps Sports: ESPN+ for $10.99/month, individual team subscriptions Missing: Cable news networks, extensive sports coverage

What You Lose vs What You Gain

Switching from Spectrum Cable to Streaming

You Lose:

• FanDuel Sports Network (Brewers/Bucks games)
• Some premium channels (unless you pay extra)
• Channel surfing experience
• One consolidated bill

You Gain:

• $4,500 savings over 5 years
• Unlimited DVR storage
• Watch anywhere on any device
• No contracts or hidden fees
• Better user interface and search
• On-demand content included

Switching to Antenna + Streaming Hybrid

You Lose:

• Cable news networks (CNN, Fox News, MSNBC)
• Comprehensive sports package
• Convenience of everything in one place

You Gain:

• $6,600+ savings over 5 years
• Best picture quality (uncompressed over-the-air)
• Never lose signal during storms
• No monthly fees for local channels
• Complete control over what you pay for
• Ability to customize your exact viewing needs

Milwaukee-Specific Considerations

Local Channel Performance

Antenna Reception: Excellent throughout metro Milwaukee

• Broadcast towers: Located in Mequon, Brown Deer, and Oak Creek
• Coverage: Reliable reception from Waukesha to Racine
• Picture quality: Better than cable/streaming (uncompressed)

Spectrum vs Streaming Internet Requirements

Spectrum Internet speeds for streaming:

• Standard: 200 Mbps ($49.99/month) - Good for 2-3 streams
• Ultra: 400 Mbps ($69.99/month) - Good for 4-6 streams
• Gig: 1000 Mbps ($89.99/month) - Unlimited streaming

Sports Coverage Reality Check

Packers games: 95% available over antenna (FOX6, TMJ4) Brewers games: 60% on FanDuel Sports Network (cable/FuboTV only) Bucks games: 70% on FanDuel Sports Network (cable/FuboTV only)

Real Milwaukee Customer Examples

The Kowalski Family - West Allis

Previous setup: Spectrum TV Gold + Internet ($210/month) New setup: Antenna + YouTube TV + Spectrum Internet ($95/month) Annual savings: $1,380 What they kept: All Packers games, most entertainment What they lost: Some Brewers games (use sports bar for playoffs)

The Johnson Household - Brookfield

Previous setup: Spectrum TV Silver + Internet ($165/month) New setup: Premium antenna + Netflix + Disney+ + Spectrum Internet ($75/month) Annual savings: $1,080 What they kept: All local channels in 4K quality, family entertainment What they lost: Live cable news (use news apps instead)

The Martinez Apartment - Third Ward

Previous setup: Spectrum TV Select + Internet ($135/month) New setup: Hulu + Live TV + Spectrum Internet ($133/month) Annual savings: $24 (plus no contracts, better features) What they kept: Same channels, added unlimited DVR What they lost: Nothing significant

Our Recommendations by Viewer Type

🏆 Best Overall Value: Antenna + Streaming Hybrid

Total 5-year cost: $3,649 Best for: Families wanting maximum savings with good channel selection Setup: Premium antenna + Netflix + Disney+ + Spectrum Internet

🥈 Best for Sports Fans: YouTube TV + Internet

Total 5-year cost: $5,760
Best for: Viewers who need comprehensive sports but can live without FanDuel Sports Network Setup: YouTube TV + Spectrum 200 Mbps Internet

🥉 Best for Convenience: Hulu + Live TV + Internet

Total 5-year cost: $5,760 Best for: Families who want streaming convenience plus Disney Bundle Setup: Hulu + Live TV + Spectrum Internet + Disney Bundle included

Getting Started: Your Action Plan

Step 1: Audit Your Current Viewing

Track what you actually watch for 2 weeks:

• How many hours of local TV per week?
• Which cable channels do you regularly watch?
• How important are Brewers/Bucks games?

Step 2: Test Antenna Reception

• Order a $30 indoor antenna from Amazon
• Test reception quality in your neighborhood
• Return if unsatisfied (most have 30-day guarantees)

Step 3: Calculate Your Personal Savings

Use our cost calculator:

• Current Spectrum bill: $____
• Proposed new setup: $____
• Monthly savings: $____
• 5-year savings: $____ x 60 months

Step 4: Transition Gradually

Month 1: Set up antenna and streaming service Month 2: Test new setup thoroughly Month 3: Cancel Spectrum TV (keep internet)

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Will I lose picture quality? A: Antenna provides better quality than cable. Streaming quality equals or exceeds cable on good internet.

Q: What about bad weather? A: Modern antennas rarely lose signal. Streaming continues unless internet is down.

Q: Can I record shows? A: Yes! Streaming DVRs are better than cable DVRs - unlimited storage and 9-month retention.

Q: What if I hate it? A: No contracts with streaming. You can switch back to cable anytime, though you'll likely pay higher rates.

The Bottom Line: Milwaukee's Best Value

For the average Milwaukee household spending $180/month on Spectrum cable TV:

Switching to antenna + streaming hybrid saves $6,600 over 5 years while maintaining access to 90% of your current viewing.

Switching to streaming-only saves $4,500 over 5 years while actually improving your viewing experience with unlimited DVR and mobile access.

Staying with cable costs an extra $6,600 over 5 years for minimal additional value.

The math is clear: Unless you absolutely must have every single cable channel, cord-cutting will save you thousands while giving you a better viewing experience.

---

Ready to start saving? Milwaukee Cord Cutting offers personalized consultations to design the perfect setup for your viewing habits and budget. We'll even help you set up your antenna and streaming services. Schedule your consultation today.